For two years, Florida officials have said the state’s home insurance market is getting better, but homeowners see it differently. A University of North Florida poll of 1,511 Florida homeowners, published September 25 by the South Florida Sun Sentinel and Orlando Sentinel, found that 55% see no sign the market is improving and another 26% think it’s getting worse. Nearly half of longtime homeowners said their premiums had gone up 50% or more in five years.
The poll also asked who the 2022–23 insurance law changes mainly helped, and 69% said insurance companies. That included 79% of Democrats, 74% of independents and 57% of Republicans, showing this opinion extends beyond party lines. Only 16% said consumers benefitted the most.
On the same day, the Sentinel newspapers released a report raising serious questions about what was going on inside Florida’s insurance companies while homeowners were being asked to give up some of their rights.
What the report shows
The newspapers published a state-ordered review of the money Florida home insurance companies paid to their own affiliated companies, which were often controlled by the same executives who ran the insurance companies. The state’s insurance regulators ordered the review, paid $150,000 for it, and received it in the spring of 2022. It looked at 53 insurance companies from 2017 through 2019.
Leaving out a few extreme cases, the insurance companies reported losing about $432 million over those three years, while their affiliated companies reported making about $1.3 billion. At some insurance companies, an affiliated company that sold and managed the policies took between 20 and 34 cents of every dollar homeowners paid in premiums. When all the fees paid to affiliated companies were added up, the total reached as high as 63 cents on the dollar.
The consultant who wrote the report found that 20 insurance companies made payments to affiliated companies that were not “fair and reasonable.” She also warned that these fees could be used to get around limits on how much money owners can pull out of an insurance company. Some of the insurance companies in the report had already been shut down by the time it was finished, and others failed later.
The report does not prove that these payments caused any particular company to fail. It does show that regulators had been warned money might be flowing out of insurance companies, where the state keeps watch, and into affiliated companies, where regulators have no oversight. The report also raised concerns that these deals could make it harder for regulators to make sure insurers had enough money to pay claims, and those concerns should have been taken seriously.
Instead, the state’s insurance regulators now call the report a flawed, outdated draft, though the consultant who wrote it has said otherwise. Lawmakers debating major changes to Florida’s insurance laws in 2022 never saw it.
The House asked questions
When parts of the report first came out in 2025, the Republican-led Florida House wanted answers. In March 2025, a House insurance subcommittee spent about three hours questioning the current and former state insurance commissioners about the payments to affiliated companies and why a report the state ordered and paid for had been kept from the public for years. The following month, the subcommittee called the report’s author to testify. Under oath, she said her firm had delivered its final draft to regulators in April 2022, never received questions or requested changes, and considered the job finished.
This year, the House passed HB 1399 by a bipartisan vote of 106–3. The bill would require insurers to report their deals with affiliated companies to state regulators, but it died in the Senate without a single hearing. In contrast, after the Sentinel newspapers got a full, unredacted copy of the report through a public records request, the Senate demanded the newspapers destroy it and warned of possible civil or criminal consequences.
When an insurance company fails, Florida homeowners pay
When the state shuts down a failed insurance company, a state-created fund called the Florida Insurance Guaranty Association steps in to pay many of the remaining claims. To cover those costs, the fund charges insurance companies doing business in Florida, and they pass that charge straight on to homeowners as an extra fee on their bills.
Florida homeowners have paid those fees many times. After a wave of insurance company failures, homeowners were charged extra fees of 0.7%, 1.3% and another 0.7%, and because some of those overlapped, policies carried a 2% charge for part of that time. In 2023, a separate 1% emergency fee was added to pay claims left behind when United Property & Casualty failed, and that fee did not end until September 30, 2026.
Because homeowners covered the cost of these failures, they have a stake in how the failed companies handled their money. If money that could have helped an insurer pay claims was going to companies controlled by the same people instead, every homeowner who paid those fees has a right to know whether those deals were fair.
A healthier insurance industry isn’t enough
While four out of five homeowners in the UNF poll said the market is stuck or getting worse, the insurance industry sees a turnaround. The Insurance Information Institute, an industry group, has called Florida’s market “vastly improved,” pointing to fewer homes insured by Citizens, the state-run insurer of last resort, along with smaller rate increases, new companies coming into the state and lower costs for the insurance coverage that insurance companies buy for themselves.
Some of that is true. Insurers are making more money, Citizens has dropped nearly one million policies, and rate increases have slowed. A healthier insurance industry, though, doesn’t automatically mean homeowners are getting better coverage or lower premiums.
Claims are a good example. The Wall Street Journal reported this year that in 2024, Florida had the highest rate in the country of homeowners insurance claims closed without any payment, with more than two out of every five claims ending with nothing paid. Before Florida made sweeping changes to homeowners’ legal rights, that figure was 36%; in 2024 it was 44%. Not every unpaid claim is an unfair denial, since the damage may cost less than the deductible, the homeowner may withdraw the claim, or there may be another legitimate reason. But at the same time lawmakers were limiting homeowners’ ability to challenge their insurer in court, regulators were approving policy changes that reduced the coverage homeowners were paying for and gave insurance companies more room to deny claims by blaming the damage on flooding.
Homeowners are now more likely to be told their claim isn’t covered and less able to fight back when they are. For that reason, lawmakers should look beyond insurance company profits and how many homes Citizens insures when deciding whether Florida’s insurance market is working. Florida homeowners are paying far more for insurance than they did a few years ago, and many also have higher deductibles and policies that leave them on the hook for more of the cost when catastrophes happen. Homeowners need to know whether they can afford their premium, whether their policy covers what matters and whether the company will pay when disaster strikes, in addition to whether their insurer is financially sound.
These questions will outlast the election
The 2026 election will soon be over, but the questions raised by this report will remain. Why were regulators warned about possibly unfair payments to affiliated companies while Florida insurance companies were claiming losses? Where did the money go? Did these payments weaken companies that later failed? Why didn’t lawmakers get to see the state’s report while they were rewriting Florida’s insurance laws? Who kept the report’s results from becoming public? And what protections are in place today to make sure this can’t happen again?
When the new Legislature meets, the Florida Justice Association will work with returning and newly elected lawmakers to push for more transparency and stronger oversight of Florida’s home insurance industry. A healthy insurance market should mean reasonable premiums, real coverage, and financially sound insurance companies that hold up their end of the deal, in addition to profitable companies and fewer homes in Citizens.
Florida homeowners paid their premiums, and they paid again through extra fees when insurance companies failed. They deserve to know where their money went, whether regulators did enough to protect it, and whether the companies collecting their premiums are keeping the promises they made. Lawmakers should get them those answers.

Comments (0)